Fish Tank HW 13.12.18

How useful has an ideological critical approach been in understanding binary oppositions in the narratives of your chosen films?
The narrative of Fish Tank does not really provide a wide variety of enigmatical or hinting codes throughout its 2h 4m runtime, thus making way for the spectator to understand and form sympathy for the characters of the film or contrastingly feel an indefference towards a character (an antagonist perhaps). The ideological critical approach use in this film, known as british social realism, presents an authentic, gritty prespective on the lives of individuals in low ecomimically gifted children. Certain moments in the film show the desperate scenearios these individuals have to go through, such as Mia’s fatherless child hood or kayla’s young smoking habit. The way these characters are represented in the film spark thought in a spectator’s mind about the different situations others find themselves, and certain scenes encourage the spectator to imagine themself in a situation one like Mia finds herself in.
After establishing that whilst watching this film, it’s suggested that the audienc is meant to support these character’s actions, especially the protagonist: Mia. Therefore binary oppositions are used to represent Mia, for example, in an area of conflict. A realization of this may be the binary opposition of adults vs. children; Mia’s dispute and dislike of her mother is prominent through the film, as we view the film via Mia’s prespective. However, the final dance scene in fact proposes that Mia’s mother only wanted the best for her.


Comments

  1. Miss CraderDecember 18, 2018 at 4:49 AM


    Paragraph 1:
    "The narrative of Fish Tank does not really provide a wide variety of enigmatical or hinting codes throughout its 2h 4m runtime, thus making way for the spectator to understand and form sympathy for the characters" - do you mean there are no enigma codes? I think enigma codes play a prominent part in the film (such as the enigma code over Connor's true intentions towards Mia - is he paternal or predatory?).
    "The ideological critical approach use in this film, known as british social realism" - British social realism is a genre, defined by certain micro features (such as gritty realism and authenticity), rather than an ideological critical approach. Your focus should either be on feminism or class.

    Paragraph 2:
    "However, the final dance scene in fact proposes that Mia’s mother only wanted the best for her. " - Overall, this paragraph - and the essay as a whole - is lacking in specificity. This means that there is not enough attention paid to key scenes. So, in this dance scene, how are the characters represented through micro features? What is the camera doing? Is it static? Handheld? What shot sizes are used? How is the sequence edited? In terms of blocking and proxemics (mise-en-scene), how are the characters positioned, and why is this significant? Is the diegetic music (Nas' Life's a Bitch) important? You need to focus in on key scenes and analyse them in detail.

    Finally, overall, this is rather brief - you want to aim for at least half to three-quarters of a page for each analytical paragraph. You will be able to write more for each paragraph by focusing on key scenes, using key terminology.

    Mr Boon

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The oedipal trajectory

The oedipal trajectory - Males - Summary A male child, who at first is bonded with his mother, imagines himself a united whole with her. However, when held up to a mirror, he perceives his difference from her. He becomes aware of the illusion of unity and still desires it. The desire now because sexual. He comes to hate his father, as his father has ‘lawful’ access to the mother. The child perceives this difference as one of castration: he sees the mother as castrated. To identify with her would this mean he would be without his penis - in identifying with her he becomes like her; in uniting with her, he runs the risk of castration from his father (he assumes the father has this power) He attempts to identify with the father; he sets about trying to find a female. The male child can now move towards social stability and continue the cycle. Application in Film Narrative In cinematic narrative, the male protagonist moves, through the resolution of a crisis, ...
Read more

Section C assesment 21.01.2018

Image
The craft of creating a film, who’s narrative structure presents certain binary oppositions that when looked at in depth have connecitons to an ideological critical approach can sometimes be used to understand things like the reasoning for an auter’s methods and style per say. In the Andrea Arnold film, Fishtank , one of the opposition that exist is the Youth vs. Adult oppsition that exists between character’s such as Mia and her mother, Joanne, or even some may interpret the relationship beteen Tyla and Mia to represent a Binary oppsition. However the more intriguing Youth vs Old binary conflict is the one between Mia and Conor, which throughout the film’s runtime progresses to become a maternal opposition, and eventually interfers with a seperate opposition - the one between Mia and Connor’s legitimate daughter. For instance, at first sight, Mia recognises Conor as a stranger - one which naturaly doesn’t to spend time with her out ...
Read more